Baccanti ebbre e ninfomani tra la fine della Repubblica e la prima età imperiale

Title: Baccanti ebbre e ninfomani tra la fine della Repubblica e la prima età imperiale
Variant title:
  • Drunken and nymphomaniac Bacchae between the late Republic and early Empire
Source document: Graeco-Latina Brunensia. 2023, vol. 28, iss. 1, pp. 19-31
Extent
19-31
  • ISSN
    1803-7402 (print)
    2336-4424 (online)
Type: Article
Language
 

Notice: These citations are automatically created and might not follow citation rules properly.

Abstract(s)
Maenads in pop culture are usually women with a strong eroticism, distinguished by sexual addiction and pure lust, malice, and murders. However, the maenads in Ancient Greek iconography and drama were completely different, not connected to the sexual sphere or to the manipulation of men. Ancient Greek maenads preserve their chastity, and their task is to honor Dionysus with dances and rites. The aim of this paper is to reconstruct the common thread that has led to this contemporary sexual and gloomy distinctive characterization of maenads in modern media and to understand where this dark vision of maenadism comes from. The stages on this journey through times past are the Bacchanalia scandal (186 B.C.), the black legend of Messalina, some cases of Christian condemnations, and the conception of maenads during the Renaissance and Victorian Hellenism.
References
[1] Albrecht, D. (2016). Hegemoniale Männlichkeit bei Titus Livius. Heidelberg: Verlag Antike.

[2] Azzetta, L. (2012). Andrea Lancia, Chiose alla 'Commedia' (Vol. 1–2). Roma: Salerno Editrice.

[3] Bérard, C. (1992). Phantasmatique érotique dans l'orgiasme dionysiaque. Kernos. Revue internationale et pluridisciplinaire de religion grecque antique, 5, 13–26.

[4] Bérard, C., & Bron, C. (1986). Bacchos au coeur de la citè. Le thiase dionisyaque dans l'espace politique. In Iidem (Eds.), L'association dionysiaque dans les sociétés anciennes. Actes de la table ronde, Rome, mai 1984 (Collection de l'Ecole Française de Rome, 89; pp. 13–30). Roma: École française de Rome.

[5] Blanchemain Faucon, L. (2019). The "permeable I"/Eye. Revue Canadienne d'études cinématographiques. Canadian Journal of Film Studies, 28(2), 65–80.

[6] Bocciolini Palagi, L. (2007). La trottola di Dioniso: motivi dionisiaci nel VII libro dell'Eneide. Bologna: Pàtron.

[7] Bravo, B. (1997). Pannychis e simposio. Feste private notturne di donne e uomini nei testi letterari e nel culto. Pisa – Roma: Ist. Ed. e Poligrafici Internazionali.

[8] Bremmer, J. N. (2019). The World of Greek Religion and Mythology. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.

[9] Brescia, G. (2009). Le ragioni del sangue. Storie d'incesto e fratricidio nella declamazione latina. Napoli: Loffredo.

[10] Carlà-Uhink, F. (2018). Nocturnal religious rites in the Roman religion and in early Christianity. In A. Chaniotis, & P. Derron (Eds.), La nuit. Imaginaire et réalités nocturnes dans le monde gréco-romain. Neuf exposés suivis de discussions (pp. 331–360). Genève: Fondation Hardt.

[11] Cermatori, L. (2013). "Eadem impia fama": il ritratto della fama secondo Seneca (epist. 13). Maia: Rivista di letterature classiche, 65(2), 288–307.

[12] Chastenet, G. (2017). Lucrezia Borgia. La perfida innocente. Milano: Mondadori.

[13] Cole, S. G. (1980). New Evidence for the Mysteries of Dionysos. Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies, 21, 223–238.

[14] de Cazanove, O. (1983). Lucus Stimulae. Les aiguillons des Bacchanales. Mélanges d'Archéologie et d'Histoire de l'école Française de Rome, Antiquité, 95, 55–113.

[15] de Cazanove, O. (1987). Exesto. L'incapacité sacrificielle des femmes ŕ Rome (ŕ propos de Plut., Q.R., 85). Phoenix. The journal of the Classical Association of Canada, 41(2), 159–173.

[16] des Bouvrie, S. (1997). Euripides' Bakkhai and maenadism. Classica et mediaevalia: Revue danoise d'histoire et de philologie publiée par la Société danoise pour les études anciennes et médiévales, 48, 75–114.

[17] Dictionnaire de l'Académie Française (2005). (9. ed.; T. 1). Paris: Académie Française.

[18] Dodds, E. R. (1940). Maenadism in the Bacchae. Harvard Theological Review, 33(3), 155–176.

[19] Dubourdieu, A. (2011). La définition de la norme religieuse dans l'affaire des Bacchanales. In B. Cabouret, & M. O. Charles-Laforge (Eds.), La norme religieuse dans l'Antiquité. Colloque organisé les 14 et 15 décembre 2007 par les Universités Lyon 2 et Lyon 3. (pp. 11–24). Paris: De Boccard.

[20] Ferrara, P. (2020). Μαινάς. Studio sulle menadi nella statuaria greca e romana. Roma: Arbor Sapientiae Editore.

[21] Flower, H. J. (2000). Fabula de Bacchanalibus: the Bacchanalian Cult of the Second Century BC and Roman Drama. In G. Manuwald (Ed.), Identität und Alterität in der frührömischen Tragödie (pp. 23–35). Würzburg: Ergon.

[22] Fuhrer, T. (2011). Inszenierungen von Göttlichkeit. Die politische Rolle von Dionysos/Bacchus in der römischen Literatur. In R. Schlesier (Ed.), A different god? Dionysos and ancient polytheism. (pp. 373–389). Berlin: de Gruyter.

[23] Gallini, G. (1970). Protesta e integrazione nella Roma antica. Bari: Editori Laterza.

[24] Gallo, A. (2017). Senatus consulta ed edicta de Bacchanalibus: documentazione epigrafica e tradizione liviana. Bollettino di studi latini: periodico quadrimestrale d'informazione bibliografica, 47(2), 519–540.

[25] GDLI = Battaglia, S. et al. (Eds.). (1994). Grande dizionario della lingua italiana (Vol. X). Torino: UTET [online available at https://www.gdli.it/sala-lettura/vol-x/10; accessed 08.04.2023].

[26] Granet, J. (1990). Dionysos contre Rome. Pallas: revue d'études antiques, 36, 53–70.

[27] Heilmann, W. (1985). Coniuratio impia. Die Unterdrückung der Bacchanalien als ein Beispiel für römische Religionspolitik und Reliogiosität. Der altsprachliche Unterricht: Arbeitshefte zu seiner wissenschaftlichen Begründung und praktischen Gestalt, 28(2), 22‒41.

[28] Heinemann, A. (2016). Der Gott des Gelages. Dionysos, Satyrn und Mänaden auf attischem Trinkgeschirr des 5. Jahrhunderts v.Chr. Berlin – Boston: de Gruyter.

[29] Heiser, S. (2008). Bocksfüße: Dionysische Capricci in Malerei und Graphik aus Berliner Beständen. In R. Schlesier, & A. Schwarzmaier (Eds.), Dionysos – Verwandlung und Ekstase (pp. 118–131). Regensburg: Schnell & Steiner.

[30] Henrichs, A. (1982). Changing Dionysiac identities. In B. F. Meyer, & E. P. Sanders (Eds.), Jewish and Christian self-definition (Vol. 3; pp. 137–160, 213–236). London: SCM Press.

[31] Henrichs, A. (1984). Male intruders among the Maenads. The so-called male celebrant. In H. D. Evjen (Ed.), Mnemai. Classical studies in memory of Karl K. Hulley (pp. 69–91). Chico, Calif.: Scholars Press.

[32] Henrichs, A. (2008). Dionysische Imaginationswelten: Wein, Tanz, Erotik. In R. Schlesier, & A. Schwarzmaier (Eds.), Dionysos – Verwandlung und Ekstase (pp. 18–27). Regensburg: Schnell & Steiner.

[33] Il Nuovo De Mauro online. (2023). Il dizionario di italiano dalla a alla z (ed. Giovanni de Mauro et al.). Roma: Internazionale spa [online available at https://dizionario.internazionale.it/parola/menade; accessed 08.04.2023].

[34] Jaccottet, A.-F. (2003). Choisir Dionysos. Les associations dionysiaques ou la face cachée du dionysisme (Vol. 1–2). Zürich: Akanthus Verlag.

[35] Jameson, M. (2014). The asexuality of Dionysus. In M. Jameson et al. (Eds.), Cults and Rites in Ancient Greece: Essays on Religion and Society (pp. 62–81). Cambridge: CUP.

[36] Joshel, S. R. (1995). Female Desire and the Discourse of Empire: Tacitus's Messalina. Signs: journal of women in culture and society, 21(1), 50–82.

[37] Kern, O. (1900). Die Inschriften von Magnesia am Maeander. Berlin: Spemann.

[38] Kraemer, R. S. (1979). Ecstasy and Possession: The Attraction of Women to the Cult of Dionysos. Harvard Theological Review, 72, pp. 55–80.

[39] Krummen, E. (2004). Dido als Mänade und tragische Heroine: Dionysische Thematik und Tragödientradition in Vergils Didoerzählung. Poetica: Zeitschrift für Sprach- und Literaturwissenschaft, 36(1–2), 25–69.

[40] Latte, K. (1960). Römische Religionsgeschichte. München: Beck.

[41] Lindblom, A. (2011). Take a Walk on the Wild Side: The behaviour, attitude and identity of women approached by Satyrs on Attic red-figure vases from 530 to 400 B.C. Stockholm: Department of Archaeology and Classical Studies, Stockholm University.

[42] Mac Góráin, F. (2020). Introduction. Dionysus in Rome: Accommodation and resistance. In F. Mac Góráin (Ed.), Dionysus and Rome. Religion and Literature (pp. 1–38). Berlin: De Gruyter.

[43] McGlashan, V. (2022). The Bacchants Are Silent. Using Cognitive Science to Explore the Experience of the Oreibasia. In E. Eidinow et al. (Eds.), Cognitive Approaches to Ancient Religious Experience (pp.145–166). Cambridge: CUP.

[44] Manuwald, G. (2020). Dionysus/Bacchus/Liber in Cicero. In F. Mac Góráin (Ed.), Dionysus and Rome. Religion and Literature (pp. 157–175). Berlin: De Gruyter.

[45] Marzocchi, I. (2016). "Farsi donna". Omosessualità, femminilizzazione e colpa nella cultura greca. Roma: Stamen.

[46] Massa, F. (2021). Menadi, prostitute, devote. Modelli di mania bacchica nell'età imperiale. In D. Bonanno, & I. Buttitta (Eds.), Narrazioni e rappresentazioni del sacro femminile. Atti del convegno internazionale di studi in memoria di Giuseppe Martorana (pp. 247–260). Palermo: Edizioni Museo Pasqualino.

[47] Merkelbach, R. (1972). Milesische Bakchen. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik, 9, 77–83.

[48] McNally, S. (1984). The Maenad in early Greek Art. In J. Peradotto, & J. P. Sullivan (Eds.), Women in the Ancient World. The Arethusa Papers (pp. 107–141). Albany, NY: State Univ. of New York Press.

[49] Montanari, E. (1983). Funzione della sovranità e feste del vino nella Roma repubblicana. Studi e materiali di storia delle religioni, 49(2), 243–262.

[50] Mowat, C. (2021). Don't be a drag, just be a priest: The clothing and identity of the galli of Cybele in the Roman Republic and Empire. Gender & History, 33(2), 296–313.

[51] Nauta, R. R., & Harder A. (Eds.). (2004). Catullus' Poem on Attis. Text and Contexts. Leiden: Brill.

[52] Nilsson, M. P. (1957). The Dionysiac mysteries of the Hellenistic and Roman Age. Lund: Gleerup.

[53] Olsson, V. (2006). The Lenaia vases revisited. Image, ritual and Dionysian women. Göteborg: Univ., Akad. avh.

[54] Olverson, T. D. (2010). Women writers and the dark side of late-Victorian Hellenism. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

[55] Pailler, J.-M. (1988). Bacchanalia, la répression de 186 AV. J.–C. á Rome et en Italie. Vestiges, images, tradition. Rome: École Française.

[56] Pailler, J.-M. (2000). Quand la femme sentait le vin. Variations sur une image antique et moderne. Pallas: revue d'études antiques, 53, 73–100.

[57] Paleothodoros, D. (2008). Espace public et espace domestique dans l'imagerie attique des rituels dionysiaques du Ve siècle av. J.–C. In S. Estienne (Ed.), Image et religion dans l'antiquité gréco-romaine. Actes du colloque de Rome, 11–13 décembre 2003 (pp. 231–242). Naples: Centre Jean Bérard.

[58] Panoussi, V. (2003). Ego maenas: maenadism, marriage, and the construction of female identity in Catullus 63 and 64. Helios: journal devoted to critical and methodological studies of classical culture, literature and society, 30(2),101–126.

[59] Panoussi, V. (2009). Greek tragedy in Vergil's "Aeneid": Ritual, empire, and intertext. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

[60] Patzelt, M. (2019). Praying as a 'Woman among Men'. Religion in the Roman Empire, 5(2), 271–291.

[61] Peirce, S. (1998). Visual language and concepts of cult on the Lenaia Vases. Classical Antiquity, 17, 59–95.

[62] Piccaluga, G. (1964). Bona Dea. Due contributi all'interpretazione del suo culto. Studi e materiali di storia delle religioni, 35, 195–237.

[63] Pomeroy, S. B. (2002). Spartan women. Oxford: university Press.

[64] Rolle, A. (2017). Dall'Oriente a Roma. Cibele, Iside e Serapide nell'opera di Varrone. Pisa: Edizioni ETS.

[65] Santoro L'Hoir, F. (2006). Tragedy, Rhetoric and the Historiography of Tacitus' Annales. Ann Arbor, Mich.: Univ. of Michigan Press.

[66] Schmidt, M. (2000). Rituelle Frauengelage auf einer noch unbekannten attischen Vase. Bulletin de correspondance hellénique, Suppl. 38, 433–442.

[67] Schmitt Pantel, P. (2011). Dionysos, the Banquet and Gender. In R. Schlesier (Ed.), A different god? Dionysos and ancient polytheism (pp. 119–136). Berlin: de Gruyter.

[68] Skinner, M. B. (1997). Ego Mulier: The Construction of Male Sexuality in Catullus. In J. P. Hallett, & M. B. Skinner (Eds.), Roman sexualities (pp. 129–150). Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press.

[69] Sokolowski, F. (1955). Lois sacrées de l'Asie Mineure. Paris: de Boccard.

[70] Sokolowski, F. (1969). Lois sacrées des cités grecques. Paris: de Boccard.

[71] Šterbenc Erker, D. (2011). Stimme und Klang im Bacchuskult: die ululatio. In E. Meyer-Dietrich (Ed.), Laut und Leise: der Gebrauch von Stimme und Klang in historischen Kulturen (pp. 173‒194). Bielefeld: Transcript-Verlag.

[72] Šterbenc Erker, D. (2013). Religiöse Rollen römischer Frauen in "griechischen" Ritualen. Stuttgart: Steiner.

[73] Stockert, W. (1972). Die Anspielungen auf die Bacchanalien in der Aulularia (406–414) und anderen Plautuskomödien. In R. Hanslik (Ed.), Antidosis: Festschrift für Walther Kraus zum 70. Geburtstag (pp. 398–407). Wien: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften.

[74] Takács, S. A. (2000). Politics and Religion in the Bacchanalian Affair of 186 BCE. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, 100, 301–310.

[75] Treccani online. (2023). Roma: Istituto della Enciclopedia Italiana fondata da Giovanni Treccani S.p.A. [online available at https://www.treccani.it/vocabolario/baccante2/; accessed 08.04.2023].

[76] Turcan, R. (1989). Les cultes orientaux dans le monde romain. Paris: Les Belles Lettres.

[77] Valdés Guía, M. (2020). Prácticas rituales y discursos femeninos en Atenas. Los espacios sacros de la gyne. Sevilla: Editorial Universidad de Sevilla; Madrid: Universidad Autonoma de Madrid.

[78] Versnel, H. S. (1993). Inconsistencies in Greek and Roman religion, 2: Transition and reversal in myth and ritual. Leiden: Brill.

[79] Villanueva Puig, M. C. (1988). La ménade, la vigne et le vin. Sur quelques types de représentations dans la céramique attique des VIe et Ve sičcles. Revue des études anciennes, 90, 35–64.

[80] Villanueva Puig, M. C. (2009). Ménades. Recherches sur la genčse iconographique du thiase féminin de Dionysos des origines ŕ la fin de la période archaďque. Etudes anciennes. Paris: Les Belles Lettres.

[81] Von Stackelberg, K. T. (2009). Performative Space and Garden Transgressions in Tacitus' Death of Messalina. American Journal of Philology, 130(4), 595–624.

[82] Ziegler, D. (2008). Dionysos in der Apostelgeschichte – eine intertextuelle Lektüre. Berlin–Münster: Lit.